Single in Your 40s

Dating without starting over

Why can't I get past the first date?

Often it isn't one flaw. Research suggests chemistry between two specific people is hard to predict from who they are on paper, and people tend to underestimate how much a new person liked them. A few small changes still help.

A woman and a man in their forties chatting and smiling over coffee in a bright bookshop café.
Illustration. AI-generated image.

Often there isn’t one thing you’re doing wrong. Research suggests that chemistry between two particular people is hard to predict from who they are on paper, and that people tend to underestimate how much a new person liked them. That doesn’t mean nothing can change. A few small shifts usually make more difference than a total overhaul.

Why do my first dates never turn into a second?

Probably less than it feels like. Meet Corinne. She’s 44, a structural engineer, divorced for three years, with a son in high school. Since January she’s been on nine first dates. Most were pleasant. One was lovely. Not one turned into a second date. By date nine she’d started rehearsing the drive home and the list of what must be wrong with her.

Here’s what the research says about that list. In two speed-dating studies, researchers from the University of Utah, UC Davis and Northwestern gave people more than 100 questionnaires about their traits and preferences before they met.1 Those answers could partly predict who tends to like people in general and who tends to be liked.1 But they couldn’t predict who would feel drawn to whom.1 The spark between two specific people, at least in that study, didn’t come from anything you could see on paper beforehand.

So nine first dates without a second can be a run of poor fits, not a verdict.

Do they like me less than I think?

There’s a decent chance they liked you more. In a series of studies, Erica Boothby and colleagues found that after people talked with someone new, they consistently underestimated how much the other person liked them and enjoyed the conversation.2 The researchers called it the liking gap.2 It showed up with strangers in a lab, college roommates and adults at a weekend workshop, and among roommates it lasted for months.2

That matters after a first date. If you leave thinking “that was fine, they probably weren’t into it,” and they leave thinking the same, nobody texts. Two people who both enjoyed the evening can quietly let it go.

Corinne realized she’d been waiting on almost every one of those nine dates. If they didn’t reach out, she took it as an answer. She’d never once said “I’d like to see you again.”

How do I show interest without overdoing it?

Be clear and specific, not intense. A study of more than 5,000 adults described five ways people tend to show romantic interest: traditional, physical, sincere, playful and polite.3 People higher in the sincere, playful and physical styles reported more dating success.3

That doesn’t mean you need to become a different person. It suggests interest that’s visible tends to work better than interest that’s carefully hidden. In practice:

  • Say one specific thing you enjoyed: “I loved hearing about your trip to Lisbon.”
  • Be curious about how they think, not just their job and kids.
  • Let a little warmth show. A laugh you don’t suppress, eye contact, leaning in.
  • Ask for the second date before you leave, if you want one.

Is it my first dates themselves?

Sometimes the setup works against you. A few things are worth checking:

  • Length. Three-hour dinners can run out of steam. An hour over coffee, ending while it’s still good, often leaves both of you wanting more.
  • The interview. Questions about divorce, custody and careers fill the time but rarely build interest. Save the logistics for later dates.
  • Your energy. If you’re squeezing dates between work and the school run, you may arrive tired and guarded. One date a week at a time that suits you beats three exhausted ones.
  • Who you’re choosing. If you keep picking people for how they look on paper, the speed-dating research suggests that’s not where chemistry comes from.1

Should I ask for feedback?

Not from your dates. It puts them in an awkward spot and the answers are usually vague. A close friend who has seen you meet new people is better. Ask them one question: how do I come across with someone new?

Corinne asked her sister. The answer stung a little: “You’re warm with us. With new people you’re polite. Kind of like you’re at a work meeting.” That was useful. It wasn’t about her looks or her history. It was about a habit she could change.

Should I keep going, or take a break?

It depends on how you feel walking into the next one. If you’re curious and reasonably rested, keep going with the changes above. If you’re dreading it, or already expecting it to fail, a short, deliberate pause may help more than another date.

A break doesn’t mean giving up. It can be two or three weeks spent on the parts of your life that make you feel most like yourself: the friends who make you laugh, the class you’ve been meaning to take, the long run on Sunday. People often come back to dating with more warmth when they haven’t spent the previous month bracing for disappointment.

Corinne took three weeks off. When she started again, she changed two things. She kept first dates to an hour, and she said “I’d like to see you again” when she meant it. Her next first date became a second, then a third. That isn’t a promise for anyone. It’s a reminder that small changes count.

What to do tonight, and this week

Tonight

  • Look back at your last three first dates and note who reached out afterward, if anyone. Were you waiting too?
  • Write down one thing you enjoyed about each of them, even the dull ones.

This week

  • Plan a shorter first date, about an hour, somewhere easy to extend if it’s going well.
  • Say it before you leave. “I’d like to do this again” is all it takes.
  • Send the next-day text yourself, with a specific day attached.
  • Ask one honest friend how you come across with someone new.

What doesn’t the research show?

  • The speed-dating studies used 4-minute dates with unattached participants, not hour-long dates in your 40s.1
  • The liking gap was measured in conversations, not romantic dates.2
  • The flirting styles findings are correlations from a survey. Changing your style isn’t proven to change outcomes.3
  • The quiz and scripts are practical guidance, not research findings.

Try it

Which first date sounds most like yours?

Great conversation, then they never followed up

Warm, but no clear signal

The evening went well, and neither of you said so out loud. People often leave unsure of how they came across.

Your next step: Next time, say you'd like to see them again before you leave.

It felt like a job interview

Lots of facts, little feeling

Questions about work and kids fill the hour but rarely build interest. Curiosity about how someone thinks lands better.

Your next step: Swap one résumé question for one about something they love.

I liked them, but I played it cool

Interest kept under wraps

Polite and careful can read as lukewarm. Sincere interest tends to go further than a guarded one.

Your next step: Tell them one specific thing you enjoyed about the evening.

Honestly, I wasn't that into them either

Maybe it's just fit

Chemistry between two specific people is hard to predict. Some first dates simply aren't a pair, and that's no one's fault.

Your next step: Let it go without a story about what's wrong with you.

Steal this text

Say it in your own words, or start from these

  • Before you leave the date

    I had a really good time tonight. I'd like to do this again. Would you?

  • The next-day text

    Still laughing about the story with the parking ticket. Want to get dinner next week? I'm free Wednesday or Thursday.

  • Asking a friend for honest feedback

    Can I ask you something and you'll be honest? When I'm meeting someone new, how do I come across? Warm, guarded, a bit formal?

People who talk about this

Labeled by where their authority comes from. Not a ranking, not an endorsement.

  • Credentialed source

Bella DePaulo

Research and writing on single life, including people who choose to stay single and live full lives on their own terms.

Social psychologist (PhD, Harvard); academic affiliate, Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, UC Santa Barbara · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Lori Gottlieb

What happens in the therapy room, including breakups, dating choices and the stories people tell about love.

Psychotherapist; author of Maybe You Should Talk to Someone and The Atlantic's Dear Therapist column · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Marisa G. Franco

Friendship, loneliness and belonging, and how adults make and keep close friends.

Licensed counseling psychologist; PhD in Counseling Psychology, University of Maryland, where she teaches · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Pepper Schwartz

Research and writing on love, sex and relationships, including dating and partnership later in life.

Sociologist (PhD, Yale); Professor Emerita of Sociology, University of Washington · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

All 7 people we point to →

Further reading

From other publishers we trust. The full list

Sources

  1. Is romantic desire predictable? Machine learning applied to initial romantic attractionPsychological Science (Joel, Eastwick and Finkel), 2017Used for: In two speed-dating studies, participants completed more than 100 self-report measures of traits and preferences before 4-minute dates. Models predicted 4% to 18% of how much people desired others in general and 7% to 27% of how much they were desired, but could not predict desire for specific partners from any combination of those measures.
  2. The liking gap in conversations: do people like us more than we think?Psychological Science (Boothby, Cooney, Sandstrom and Clark), 2018Used for: After conversations, people systematically underestimated how much their conversation partners liked them and enjoyed their company. The gap appeared among strangers in a lab, first-year college dorm mates and adults at a workshop, and lasted for months among dorm mates.
  3. Individual differences in the communication of romantic interest: development of the Flirting Styles InventoryCommunication Quarterly (Hall, Carter, Cody and Albright), University of Kansas, 2010Used for: In a sample of 5,020 adults, researchers identified five styles of communicating romantic interest: traditional, physical, sincere, playful and polite. The physical, sincere and playful styles correlated with more dating success.
Up nextNewly single in your 40s: where do you even start?