How much should you tell someone new about your past?
By your 40s there's a marriage, or a long relationship, or several, behind you. Someone new will ask. Research on what couples avoid talking about, and why, offers a better guide than any rule about the third date.

At 25, “tell me about your exes” is a short conversation. At 45 it can include a marriage, a custody schedule, a long relationship that ended badly, and a few short ones you’d rather not itemize.
There’s no rule that tells you when to say what. There is research on what people avoid talking about in new relationships, and why. It’s more useful than a rule.
You’re not the only one holding back
When researchers asked 102 people in relationships which topics they were reluctant to raise with a partner, past relationships and past sexual experiences came up often.2 The reasons, from most to least common:
- The past belongs in the past.
- It touches on who they are, or how they’d be seen.
- It might threaten the relationship.
- It’s upsetting to go back there.
Men and women gave those reasons at nearly identical rates.2
It works the other way, too. In a 2021 study, about half of respondents said they’d rather not hear about a partner’s sexual history or infidelity, and older participants were more likely to want to avoid information about a partner.3 So the person across the table may be no more eager for your full history than you are to give it.
The middle is where it gets awkward
A 2004 study of 216 people found that how much couples avoid topics doesn’t move in a straight line as they get closer. Avoidance followed a curve, and it went up with uncertainty about the relationship.1
In plain terms: the stage where you’re not sure what this is yet, a few weeks to a few months in, is when hard topics feel hardest. Waiting until you’re sure doesn’t always happen on its own, because talking is part of what makes you sure.
What to share, and when
A practical way to think about it is in layers.
Early on: the shape. Facts that are visible anyway, or that affect logistics. “I was married for twelve years, we divorced three years ago, I have two kids who are with me half the week.” No grievances, no verdicts on the ex.
As it gets serious: the lessons. What you learned, what you’d do differently, what you need now. This is the layer that tells a new partner something useful about you.
When it’s needed: the specifics. Some details matter for the relationship, like anything to do with health, money or an ongoing co-parenting arrangement. Others are just history.
A 2026 review of 30 samples found that people tend to share a fair amount of their sexual history with partners while keeping some things to themselves, and that people seem to weigh benefits against costs when deciding.4 That’s a reasonable description of a healthy middle: open, not exhaustive.
When the other person won’t talk about theirs
If they deflect, it may be one of the four reasons above, not a secret. Ask about the shape, not the details: “How long ago was your last relationship?” is easier to answer than “What went wrong?”
If something in their past made you wary, our piece on trusting someone new after betrayal is about your side of that.
Where the research stops
These studies mostly surveyed younger adults and couples already together, at a single point in time.12 They describe what people avoid and why, not the right amount to tell. The layering approach above is our suggestion, built on those findings, not something the studies tested.
People who talk about this
- Credentialed source
Bella DePaulo
Research and writing on single life, including people who choose to stay single and live full lives on their own terms.
- Credentialed source
Lori Gottlieb
What happens in the therapy room, including breakups, dating choices and the stories people tell about love.
- Credentialed source
Marisa G. Franco
Friendship, loneliness and belonging, and how adults make and keep close friends.
- Credentialed source
Pepper Schwartz
Research and writing on love, sex and relationships, including dating and partnership later in life.
Further reading
The Gottman Institute
12 Clear Signs You Are Ready to Date Again After a Breakup (opens gottman.com)A checklist for judging emotional readiness before you open the door to dating again.