Single in Your 40s

Dating without starting over

Can it work if you're dating someone of a different religion?

Different faiths, or faith and none, are common in couples now. What the research says about how these relationships go, and the conversations that matter most.

A couple in their forties stroll through an evening food market, the man in a teal overshirt talking while the woman smiles.
Illustration. AI-generated image.

Yes, interfaith relationships can work well, and they’re common. What seems to matter most is whether you can talk openly about faith and what it shapes in daily life, not whether you share the same beliefs. In your 40s, that talk often comes with more history attached: kids, family expectations, a past marriage.

How common is this?

More than it used to be. In Pew’s 2014 Religious Landscape Study, 39% of Americans married since 2010 had a spouse from a different religious group, about double the share for those who married before 1960.1 Many of those marriages paired a Christian with someone who has no religion.1 Among unmarried couples living together, close to half were with someone of a different faith.1

Do interfaith couples break up more?

Older data says somewhat. A study using a national survey from the late 1980s found interfaith marriages ended more often than same-faith ones.3 But the gap shrank when the two religions were similar in belief and practice, or more tolerant of each other.3 That’s a correlation from decades ago, and it can’t tell you what drove the breakups.

A study of younger couples is more encouraging. Being in an interfaith relationship didn’t predict breaking up a year later, and couples who talked openly about religion reported less relationship distress.2 The sample was college students, so it’s not a perfect match for someone in midlife, but the communication finding is worth noting.

It’s not about how religious, it’s about what for

Psychologist Annette Mahoney reviewed ten years of studies on religion in families. Her conclusion was that general measures, like how often someone attends services, explain less than the specific beliefs and practices a person holds.4 Religion can strengthen or strain family relationships depending on how it’s lived.4

So “she’s Catholic and I’m not” tells you less than “she wants to go to Mass every week and hopes I’ll come sometimes.”

What to ask in the first few months

Invented example: Ravi grew up Hindu and still marks the big festivals with his family. Jen, who he’s been seeing for three months, was raised Baptist and hasn’t been to church in years. Neither thought religion was an issue until Jen’s mom asked whether Ravi would “come to the Christmas service.” It turned into a good conversation, because they treated it as a question, not a test.

Some questions that help:

  • What does your faith look like on a normal week?
  • Which traditions would you never want to give up?
  • How would your family react if we got serious?
  • If either of us has kids, how would we handle religion with them?
  • Is there anything you’d hope I’d do or join, even if you wouldn’t ask?

None of these need perfect answers. You’re looking for honesty and room to talk.

For a broader way to judge long-term fit, see how to know if someone is right for you. If kids are part of the picture, dating as a single parent in your 40s covers the logistics.

Try it

Is this something to talk through early, or something that can wait?

  1. 1/6 Whether kids you might raise together would be brought up in a faith

    Talk about it early. This is one of the big practical questions. Finding out late tends to hurt more.

  2. 2/6 Which holidays you'd each want to celebrate, and how

    Talk about it early. Holidays bring families in. Knowing what matters to each of you avoids a surprise in December.

  3. 3/6 Whether you like the same style of music at their place of worship

    It can wait. Taste matters less than whether you respect what the practice means to them.

  4. 4/6 Whether they'd expect you to convert

    Talk about it early. A quiet expectation like this can sit under everything. Ask it directly.

  5. 5/6 The exact theology of the afterlife

    It can wait. Interesting to explore over time, but not usually what makes or breaks a couple.

  6. 6/6 How their family feels about them dating outside the faith

    Talk about it early. Family reactions often shape the relationship more than the beliefs themselves.

0 to 2 right

Worth a second look

The practical questions, like family, holidays and kids, are where couples tend to get stuck. Start there.

3 to 4 right

Good sense of priorities

You see which differences have day-to-day weight. Raise the one you've been avoiding.

5 to 6 right

You know where the real issues are

Daily life and family matter most. Doctrine can be a long, curious conversation.

Steal this text

Say it in your own words, or start from these

  • Opening the topic without making it heavy

    I'd love to understand what your faith means to you day to day. Can I ask you a few questions about it over dinner?

  • Saying where you stand

    I'm not religious, but I respect that you are. I'd want us to figure out together how that works for holidays and family.

People who talk about this

Labeled by where their authority comes from. Not a ranking, not an endorsement.

  • Credentialed source

Bella DePaulo

Research and writing on single life, including people who choose to stay single and live full lives on their own terms.

Social psychologist (PhD, Harvard); academic affiliate, Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, UC Santa Barbara · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Lori Gottlieb

What happens in the therapy room, including breakups, dating choices and the stories people tell about love.

Psychotherapist; author of Maybe You Should Talk to Someone and The Atlantic's Dear Therapist column · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Marisa G. Franco

Friendship, loneliness and belonging, and how adults make and keep close friends.

Licensed counseling psychologist; PhD in Counseling Psychology, University of Maryland, where she teaches · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

  • Credentialed source

Pepper Schwartz

Research and writing on love, sex and relationships, including dating and partnership later in life.

Sociologist (PhD, Yale); Professor Emerita of Sociology, University of Washington · credential source

Profiles last checked October 1, 2026

All 7 people we point to →

Further reading

From other publishers we trust. The full list

Sources

  1. Interfaith marriage is common in U.S., particularly among the recently wedPew Research Center (Caryle Murphy), June 2, 2015 (2014 Religious Landscape Study)Used for: 39% of Americans married since 2010 had a spouse in a different religious group, compared with 19% of those who wed before 1960. 18% of recent marriages were between a Christian and a religiously unaffiliated spouse. 49% of unmarried couples living together were with someone of a different faith.
  2. Open communication and partner support in intercultural and interfaith romantic relationships: A relational maintenance approachJournal of Social and Personal Relationships (Reiter and Gee), 2008Used for: In 353 college students in relationships, more open communication about religion in interfaith couples was associated with lower relationship distress. Being in an interfaith relationship did not predict breaking up a year later.
  3. Religion as a determinant of marital stabilityDemography (Lehrer and Chiswick), 1993Used for: Using 1987 to 1988 national survey data, interfaith marriages generally had higher dissolution rates than same-faith marriages. The effect was smaller when the two religions were more similar in beliefs and practices and more tolerant of each other.
  4. Religion in Families, 1999-2009: A Relational Spirituality FrameworkJournal of Marriage and Family (Mahoney), 2010Used for: A review of a decade of peer-reviewed studies on religion in marriage and parenting, for better and worse. Concludes that specific spiritual beliefs and practices matter more than general markers of how religious someone is.
Up nextLonely being single in your 40s? What actually helps